Monday, January 21, 2013

RA 9522: Bajo de Masinloc



Chinese ‘occupation’ of Bajo de Masinloc could reduce PH territorial waters by 38 percent

by Ellen Tordesillas, VERA Files

The Philippines is at a loss over China’s declaration its ships will stay permanently in Bajo de Masinloc, a declaration some experts say could lead to the Philippines losing 38 percent of its territorial waters.

Bajo de Masinloc, a triangular-shaped coral reef formation that has several rocks encircling a lagoon, is located 124 nautical miles west of Masinloc town in Zambales in the northwestern part of the Philippines.

“The shoal is under virtual occupation by China,” said former foreign undersecretary and former Philippine Permanent Representative to the United Nations Lauro Baja.

Foreign Secretary Albert del Rosario confirmed this, saying, “In a subministerial consultation, Chinese Vice Foreign Minister Fu Ying had said to our people that China’s presence was permanent and they had no intention of withdrawing their ships from the vicinity of Bajo de Masinloc.”

The National Mapping and Resource Information Authority (NAMRIA) says Bajo de Masinloc has an area of about 120 square kilometers. It is also referred to as Panatag (calm in Pilipino) by fishermen who seek refuge in the area during stormy weather.

Its international name is Scarborough shoal after the tea-carrying British boat Scarborough which sank in the vicinity in 1784. China also claims ownership of the shoal which is 467 nautical miles away from its mainland, and refers to it as Huangyan Island.

Republic Act 9522, which defines the country’s archipelagic baseline, includes Bajo de Masinloc as part of Philippine territory. The law classifies it as a regime of islands under Art. 121 of the Law of the Sea Convention (LOSC), which means it generates its own territorial sea, exclusive economic zone (EEZ) and continental shelf.

Under UNCLOS, “an island is a naturally formed area of land, surrounded by water, which is above water at high tide.”
An island generates its own maritime regimes, which are 12 nautical miles (nm) for territorial sea, 24 nm for contiguous zone, 200 nm for EEZ and 200 nm continental shelf.

Under this definition, the Chinese claim over Baja de Masinloc means the Philippines risks losing not only the 120-square-kilometer strategically vital reef formation but also some 494,000 square kilometers EEZ, representing 38 per cent of the country’s EEZ.

One of the Philippines’ options to protest the Chinese encroachment is going to the United Nations International Tribunal on the Law of the Sea (ITLOS), the arbitration arm of UNCLOS, of which the Philippines and China are signatories.

Legal experts say the Philippines can ask the ITLOS, which does not deal with territorial disputes, to declare Bajo de Masinloc as a rock rather than an island.

UNCLOS said, “Rocks which cannot sustain human habitation or economic life of their own shall have no exclusive economic zone or continental shelf.”

Retired Philippine Navy Commodore Rex Robles, who has been to the area a few times for gunnery practice, declares that “Panatag shoal is a rock.”

“It cannot support human life. It is not an island,” he concludes.

Lawyer Romel Bagares, executive director of Center for International Law (Philippines), said RA 9522 “does not actually specify whether Bajo de Masinloc consists just of uninhabitable rocks or is capable of economic life pursuant to Art 121 of the UNCLOS. This could be one way of arguing ITLOS has jurisdiction, especially as to the interpretation of provisions. It's a pragmatic approach, no doubt.”

What is obvious, Bagares said, is that RA 9522 assumes that the shoal is part of Philippine territory in the fullest sense of the term.

Del Rosario said, “To the extent that their three ships are within our exclusive economic zone, this is in gross violation of the DOC and UNCLOS.”

DOC is the Declaration of Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea signed in 2002 by members of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, four of them part claimants to islands in the South China Sea, and China. UNCLOS is the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea.

Baja said, “When our ships withdrew from Bajo de Masinloc in June and now (we) could not access the area, the shoal became under virtual occupation by China. “

Baja, who drafted the DOC with Malaysia’s Abdul Kadir, also said Chinese occupation of the disputed shoal has changed the status quo, contrary to the DOC.

The DOC states: “The Parties undertake to exercise self-restraint in the conduct of activities that would complicate or escalate disputes and affect peace and stability including, among others, refraining from action of inhabiting on the presently uninhabited islands, reefs, shoals, cays, and other features and to handle their differences in a constructive manner.”

Baja said China is exercising what the International Court of Justice (ICJ) calls “effectivités.” “This is the basis of the Court’s decision on the Ligatan Sipadan case where the court awarded the area to Malaysia over Indonesia. Also the same principle in the case between Chile and Peru and between Nicaragua and Guatemala,” he said.

In 2002, the ICJ awarded sovereignty over Pulau Ligitan and Pulau Sipadan, two very small islands located in the Celebes Sea, off the northeast coast of the island of Borneo, to Malaysia against Indonesia giving weight to the former’s actual and continued exercise of authority over the islands.

Baja said, “We must act and interact before we lose the territory by default and/or estoppel.”

Seven months after China’s occupation of Bajo de Masinloc, the Philippines is still “reviewing” its options.

Asked about the Philippines’ response to China’s declaration it has no intentions of pulling out their ships from Panatag shoal, Del Rosario said, “We are reviewing all our options in accordance with our three track approach encompassing the political, legal and diplomatic means.”

President Benigno Aquino III has refused to discuss publicly the Philippine efforts on Bajo de Masinloc because he said doing so would be “giving the other side a preview of everything that we will do.”
He said, though, in October at a forum by the Foreign Correspondents Association of the Philippines that the matter “is still being studied by our consultants.”

Aquino added, “There are several law firms that we are consulting, conversant and very well thought of and experts in international law, to precisely chart the course of how we will utilize the legal procedures in international law to advance our claims.”

Experts point to two options available to the Philippines: the military option—which is not really an option considering the inferior state of the Philippine Navy compared with China’s naval might—and the legal option.

THE permanent stationing of three of its ships in Bajo de Masinloc is part of China’s “creeping invasion” of disputed territories in the South China Sea, a high-ranking Philippine government official said.

Bajo de Masinloc is Huangyan island to China, which has time and again reiterated “that Huangyan Island and Nansha Islands have always been parts of Chinese territory and that the People’s Republic of China has indisputable sovereignty over these islands and their adjacent waters.”

“The claim to territory sovereignty over Huangyan Island and Nansha Islands by the Philippines is illegal and invalid,” China says.

Nansha is what the Chinese call the Spratly Islands, a group of islands on the South China Sea, parts of which are being claimed by the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei and Taiwan.

China’s presence on Bajo de Masinloc is also an alarming reminder to the Philippines of how Mischief Reef came under Chinese control 18 years ago.

In the early 1990s, China had built structures it said were just fishermen’s shelters on Mischief Reef. Through the years, China added installations on the island, including a radar system.
Philippine and U.S Air Force reconnaissance revealed military structures on Mischief Reef belying Chinese claims. In January 1995, the captain of a Philippine fishing boat reported that he was arrested and detained for a week by the Chinese when he ventured into Mischief Reef.

Since then Mischief Reef has been under the control of China and inaccessible to Filipinos.

A paper titled “Geopolitics of Scarborough Shoal” written by Francois-Xavier Bonnet of the Bangkok-based Research Institute on Contemporary Southeast Asia (IRASEC) explains the importance of Huangyan Island to the bigger and long-term objective of China.

Bonnet said Huangyan Island/Bajo de Masinloc is crucial to China’s claim over the Zhongsha Qundao islands which is vital in its controversial “nine-dash line map.”

The map is called “nine-dash line” or “nine-dotted line” because it shows a series of nine dashes or dotted lines forming a ring around the South China Sea area, which China claims is part of its territory. The area includes the Spratlys group and Bajo de Masinloc.

The “nine-dash line map” puts 90 percent of the whole South China Sea under Chinese jurisdiction.

The map does not have coordinates, but was submitted by China to the United Nations on May 7, 2009.

Bonnet explained, “The Zhongsha Qundao is composed of Macclesfield Bank, Truro Shoal, Saint Esprit Shoal, Dreyer Shoal and Scarborough Shoal. All these banks and shoals, except for Scarborough Shoal, are under several meters of water even during low tide. Chinese policymakers know too well that without Huangyan island, the chance of their ownership over Zhongsha Qundao recognized is nil.” Bonnet said, “The stakes are high. If China loses Huangyan/Scarborough, it will lose Zhongsha Qundao, which could be divided by the EEZs of the neighboring countries or placed under the regime of the high seas. By consequence, China’s entire claim to the South China Sea supported by the U-shape line would be moot and academic.”

Last June, China elicited international concern when it established Sansha City on Yongxing Island in the southernmost province of Hainan. Sansha City’s territory includes the Spratlys, the Paracels and Macclesfield Bank.

Immediately after establishing Sansha City, China’s Central Military Commission, its most powerful military body, approved the deployment of a garrison of soldiers from the People’s Liberation Army to guard disputed islands.

China’s Ministry of Civil Affairs said in June that putting Macclesfield Bank, the Paracels and the Spratlys under Sansha would “further strengthen China’s administration and development” of the three island groups.

The Philippines protested the establishment of Sansha City, specifically the inclusion of a part of its territory, Macclesfield Bank, one of the largest underwater atolls in the world, covering an area of 6,500 square kilometers.

Former foreign undersecretary and Philippine Permanent Representative to the United Nations Lauro Baja said there is no doubt that China has Bajo de Masinloc in its long-term territorial design.

Incidents of Philippine Navy ships apprehending Chinese fishermen in the vicinity of Bajo de Masinloc is common. In 1999, the Philippine Navy even “accidentally” sank a Chinese fishing boat. But the conflict never went beyond the standard diplomatic protests.

Former Foreign Secretary Domingo Siazon recalled one apprehension in 1998 that was a subject of a diplomatic protest by China involving a young navy officer named Antonio Trillanes IV, who would would later on become a senator and play a controversial role in the tension between the Philippines and China over the disputed shoal.
But Philippine encounters with the Chinese in Baja de Masinloc took a different turn on April 8, 2012, when the BRP Gregorio Del Pilar, the Philippines lone modern warship acquired from the United States, arrested Chinese fishing vessels in the area.

Philippine military officials said BRP Gregorio del Pilar was due for preventive maintenance servicing in Subic at that time but was redirected to Northern Luzon as contingency undertaking for an impending North Korea rocket launch.
The combat ship was also ordered to verify reports about the presence of the Chinese fishing vessels in Bajo de Masinloc. They arrested Chinese fishermen in eight fishing boats caught with sizable quantities of endangered marine species, corals, live sharks and giant clams.

Looking back, officials say the April 8, 2012 incident gave China an excuse to occupy the area.

China immediately deployed three Chinese Marine Surveillance (CMS) ships to Bajo de Masinloc to rescue their fishermen and added more than 80 vessels as the standoff dragged on.

The Philippines later withdrew BRP Gregorio del Pilar, which was replaced by a Philippine Coast Guard ship and a research vessel by the Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources in observance of “white to white,” referring to civilian ships, and “gray to gray,” meaning navy-to-navy rules of engagement.

The standoff that lasted 57 days spilled over to the economic front with China rejecting inferior quality bananas from the Philippines and cancellation of Philippine-bound Chinese tour groups.

It was only broken upon the insistence of the United States State Department that the issue be resolved because President Barack Obama did not want it included in the agenda of his June 8, 2012 meeting with President Benigno Aquino III at the White House.

With the breakdown of communication between the straight-talking Philippine Foreign Secretary Albert Del Rosario and Chinese Ambassador Ma Keqing in Manila, U.S. Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian and Pacific Affairs Kurt Campbell proposed to Chinese Vice Foreign Minister Fu Ying in Washington D.C. that Chinese and Philippine vessels withdraw simultaneously from the disputed shoal.

By that time, Trillanes had entered the picture and was directly negotiating between Beijing and Malacañang to help de-escalate the tension.

Hours before Aquino left for London and Washington D.C. on June 4, 2012, Malacañang announced the pullout of Philippine ships from Bajo de Masinloc “consistent with our agreement with the Chinese government on withdrawal of all vessels from the shoal’s lagoon to defuse the tensions in the area.”

Diplomatic sources said Fu Ying never committed complete withdrawal of their ships from Bajo de Masinloc as there was resistance from the People’s Liberation Army, an important sector in China’s power structure.

Del Rosario said when he met with Fu Ying during her Manila visit last Oct. 19, “I was very direct in saying that the presence of their ships is in clear violation of our sovereign rights, and they must withdraw their ships at the earliest possible time.”

Fu Ying did not respond, he said.

Saturday, January 19, 2013

Election Law: RA 7941's Partylist Incumbent Filing a Candidacy

Is Bag-ao above the law?
By Alvin Capino | Posted on Jan. 18, 2013 at 12:01am | 2,448 views


President Benigno Aquino III has warned embattled Cebu Gov. Gwen Garcia to adhere to the law. We wish the President can convince his allies to do the same.

It would seem, however, that Mr. Aquino’s allies are above the law and his “tuwid na daan” do not apply to them,

Take the case of Rep. Arlene “Kaka” Bag-ao who, if the law is adhered to strictly, should have already been removed from the official roster of the House of Representatives.

Bag-ao, a party list congressman representing Akbayan, is running for a regular seat for the congressional district in island province of Dinagat under the Liberal Party.

The party list law is clear that she cannot continue to represent the Akbayan party list once she files a certificate as the candidate of another party.

Section 15 of Republic Act 7941, the Republic Act “providing for the election of party-list representatives through the party-list system,” clearly states that “Any elected party-list representative who changes his political party or sectoral affiliation during his term of office shall forfeit his seat.”

It should be noted, as one legal expert pointed out, that the wording of that particular provision of the Party-List law is very clear and uses the imperative “shall” which connotes that removal from the party list seat is automatic once a party list representative changes political party.

Bag-ao, a lawyer, tried to wiggle out of her legal dilemma by using the Jesuitical argument that she is just a “guest candidate” of the Liberal Party and therefore Section 12 or Republic Act 7941 does not apply to her.

An election lawyer, however, finds this excuse of Bag-ao hilarious especially since she is a lawyer. The election law expert says there is no such thing as a guest candidate. “The CONA requires that you accept the nomination and join that party.”

We researched pertinent Comelec regulations about CONA or the Certificate of Nomination and Acceptance and it was clear from the “Guidelines on the filing of Certificates of Candidacy and Nomination and Acceptance of official candidates of registered political parties or coalition of political parties in connection with the May 13, 2013 automated synchronized national, local and ARRM regional election” promulgated by Comelec on September 11, 2012.

Section 2 or the Comelec guidelines state that in the Certificate of Candidacy the candidate will among others state under oath “the duly registered political party or coalition of political parties to which he belongs”.

Clearly, when Bag-ao filed her Certificate of Candidacy in October 2012 she declared under oath that she is a member of the Liberal Party and because of this sworn statement she is no longer a member of Akbayan and could no longer represent Akbayan in the House of Representatives.

But instead of being forced to step down as party list representatives by operation of law Bag-ao was “rewarded” by Malacañang with the release of P140 million in pork barrel funds by Budget Secretary Florencio Abad.

The P140 million represents the pork barrel for the Dinagat district where she is running as congressman which had not been released ever since the elected congressman in that district, Ruben Ecleo Jr., was removed from office after his conviction for a graft case was upheld by the Supreme Court.
Malacañang and Speaker Sonny Belmonte have justified the release of the Dinagat pork barrel fund to Bag-ao because she has been designated as caretaker of that district.

The Dinagat district pork barrel is of course separate and distinct from the pork barrel of Bag-ao as the Akbayan party list representative.

If the law is strictly enforced and Bag-ao is considered as automatically removed as Akbayan party-list representative when she filed her COC as a member of the LP and got a CONA certifying that she is indeed a member of the LP last October, isn’t the release of the pork barrels for Akbayan and for the Dinagat district to her illegal?

Aside from the legal issues on Bag-ao’s use of the Dinagat district pork barrel, there are also ethical issues involved. The release of the pork barrel of Dinagat district would have been no problem if Bag-ao was just a caretaker.

The controversy here is that more than a caretaker for the district, Bag-ao is a candidate as congressman for that district and it is not hard to think the many ways that she would use that huge amount as her campaign fund.

In what reeks of political opportunism, Bag-ao has used a big chunk of the Dinagat district pork barrel to purchase 77 units of multicab utility vehicles, six luxury 4X4 vehicles, nearly of which had been distributed to barangay in the municipality of Tubajon which is reportedly her political bailiwick and where she expects to get most of her votes.

With all these actuations, it is really funny to hear Bag-ao describe herself as a “principled solon”. How can you be principled when you cannot even adhere to the law?

Thursday, January 17, 2013

COMELEC 2013: Internet Political Ads

Businessworld - Meanwhile, Comelec Chairman Sixto S. Brillantes, Jr. yesterday said that political advertisements posted on the Internet will also be monitored closely by the poll body.

In a resolution promulgated last Jan. 15, the Comelec revised the implementing rules and regulations under the Fair Elections Act to include a provision that will allow the monitoring of spending on Web campaigns.

“Political advertising includes matters, not falling within the scope of personal opinion, that appear on any Internet Web site, including, but not limited to, social networks, blogging sites, and micro-blogging sites, in return for consideration, or otherwise capable of pecuniary estimation,” read the resolution.

Mr. Brillantes said in his Twitter account: “In other words, the crucial test is whether the use of Internet [or] social media incurs an expense on the part of the candidate... In such case, such online election propaganda become[s] subject of monitoring, particularly its consequence on election spending.”

He added that “text blasting” or sending numerous text messages for campaign at once is not authorized under the resolution.

“Use of it for campaign will need prior permission,” he said.

He also clarified that personal opinions or declarations of support in blogs and social media are “not considered acts of election campaigning or partisan political activity.”

The resolution will be observed at the start of the campaign period, which is from Feb. 12 to May 11 for senatorial candidates and from March 29 to May 11 for those running for a congressional seat and other local positions.

Also covered in the resolution are rules on the allowed airtime for candidates on television and radio, and allowed size of posters and other published campaign materials.


InterAksyon - The Commission on Elections has introduced the first rules on campaigning online or over the internet for the May 13, 2013 elections.

This is apparently in anticipation of candidates using cyberspace to promote themselves to the electorate during the campaign period.

Based on Comelec Resolution No. 9615, the Comelec will only allow the following sizes for online materials for each candidate.

The sizes: medium (300 width x 250 height); square pop-up (250x250); vertical rectangle (240x400); large rectangle (336x280); rectangle (180x150); 3:1 rectangle (300x100); Pop-under (7.20x300); full banner (468x60); half banner (234x60); micro bar (88x31); button 1 (120x90); button 2 (120x60); vertical banner (120x240); square button (125x125); Leaderboard (728x90); wide skyscrapers (160x600); skyscraper (120x600); and half-page ad (300x600).

The poll body added that online advertisements shall “not be published more than three times in a week per website” during the campaign period.

“For this purpose, the exhibition or display of the online advertisement for any length of time, regardless of frequency, within a 24-hour period, shall be construed as one instance of publication,” the Comelec said.

On the other hand, the poll body will be imposing stricter rules on campaigning using the broadcast media.

The same resolution stated that the number of minutes allowable to each candidate shall now be counted in total and not per television or radio station just like in the past.

For each national candidate, the commission said candidates' advertisements must not be more than a combined total of 120 minutes for TV and 180 minutes for radio.

As for local bets, TV advertisements must not be more than a collective total of 60 minutes and 90 minutes for radio.

On the other hand, Comelec Chairman Sixto Brillantes Jr. said they are also looking at implementing new rules on “tandem ads” or those that feature a party-list and a candidate.

“Tandem ads (party-list + candidate) / joint ads (multiple candidates in 1 ad) will be charged to airtime of each candidate,” he added.

Meanwhile, the poll body said the appearances and guestings on a bona fide newscast, interview, documentary that can be considered incidental to the presentation of the subjects covered by the news shall not be considered campaign propaganda.

“To determine whether the appearance in a program is bona fide, the broadcast station must show that prior approval of the commission was secured, and that candidates and parties were afforded equal opportunities to promote their candidacy,” said the resolution.

For published or printed election materials, the poll body said the maximum size of print advertisements remains to be 1/4 page in broadsheets and 1/2 page in tabloids.

“Print advertisements shall not be published more than three times a week per newspaper, magazine, or other publication during the campaign period,” the Comelec added.

Under the Omnibus Election Code, violations of the rules and regulations, based on the provisions of the Fair Election Act, shall constitute an election offense which carries a penalty of one to six years imprisonment as well as removal of right to vote and run for public office.

The campaign period for national candidates and party-lists will start on February 12 while that for local bets will begin on March 29.

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Restrictive economic provisions of the Constitution once again





The report that Speaker Feliciano Belmonte of the House and Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile will revive discussions to amend the restrictive economic provisions of the Constitution brings back to life an important issue of economic policy. It had been completely eclipsed when political theater got dominated by the impeachment of the Chief Justice.

Such an initiative will gain force if embraced further by a popular president. The amendment of restrictive economic provisions could be a manageable change agenda so long as it is not complicated by broader political questions.

“Additional arguments in favor of amending the restrictive economic provisions.” This column has devoted space on the subject because of its importance in tilting the nation’s potential for economic growth. The reader can consult the archives of The Philippine Star. (For those using the internet, go to: GERARDO P. SICAT Articles|philstar.com).

Below are additional arguments that I offer to persuade President Aquino to include such reforms in his agenda so that he can move camp and give the marching orders to the legislative leaders:
• The right time to undertake reforms is when economic expectations are low;
• The nation’s mindset should gear toward regional rather than insular economic outlook;
Business ( Article MRec ), pagematch: 1, sectionmatch: 1
• The advantages offered by the TPP (Trans Pacific Partnership) within the Asia-Pacific network of economic cooperation in trade could be lost by default without constitutional amendments; and
• The restrictive nationalism indicated by the constitutional provisions has encouraged extractive economic institutions to dominate the country’s development effort and do not encourage inclusive economic development prospects.

“The right time for reform.” World economic conditions are relatively difficult at the moment. Expectations are low. The economies of the United States, Europe, and Japan – three important regional engines of world economic growth – are still in a troublesome state.

The right time to undertake reforms is when expectations are low. When the prospects turn brighter, the proper policies are already in place and the country can reap the benefits. Thus, we do not miss the boat.
Moreover, even as Philippine economic assessments have improved, which give the country much notice as a “comeback” and “rising” economy, undertaking the reforms will add more positive factors. This will create more momentum for economic growth.

“The change in mindset from domestic to regional and international.” It’s time to change the nation’s mindset and those of the country’s business leaders. They should now be encouraged to view the domestic market as something beyond that the Philippine market. It adds the potential market of the other ASEAN member countries.

The ASEAN Free Trade Area widens the boundaries of our national market. Thus, our outlook as a nation should embrace a larger economic market and business plans of our larger enterprises should be encouraged to widen their outlooks.
So should our domestic policies in encouraging economic growth. This should make us more into a regional and international competitor rather than an insular market that is concerned alone with a limited economic market.

Our high-growth neighbors think regional and their economies are further outward looking. That makes their enterprises competitive regionally and internationally.

Foreign direct investments located in our country have long adjusted their economies on a regional footing. When they make investment plans, they factor in regional considerations within the ASEAN. A recent example of this was the Ford closure of its manufacturing plant in the country (which I discussed recently in this column).

If we change our mindset as a nation, we can adjust more quickly to our needs to stay highly competitive. We will then be able to rearrange our investment incentives pattern so that we do not simply direct them toward developing the domestic market for local businesses.

Incidentally, the old mindset is still behind the investment incentives laws under the Board of Investments. Yet our export incentives under the PEZA are geared toward international markets.

There is a link that is missing in these two incentives laws. The supply networks essential to support the industrial supply base of our export manufacturers in the PEZA do not exist within our boundaries as a result. The reason is that the domestic market has been nurtured by restrictive economic policies.

“The opportunities to move to higher trade agreements are beneficial.” The constitutional provisions on restrictions extend to prohibitions on the practice of the professions by foreigners.

Our human resources -- professionals and skilled labor – have roamed the world for a living. At home, we practice protectionism that would have blocked such sources of livelihood for our OFW citizens who work abroad.

The TPP (Trans Pacific Partnership) agreement is emerging as a comprehensive free trade arrangement that includes all the major countries of the Asia-Pacific Region and a few developing countries. (Remember how South Korea and Taiwan in decades past have reaped the benefits of their rapid economic growth by tapping onto the US market?)

The agreement covers freer trade in goods and services, affecting rules of origin, trade remedies, barriers to trade, intellectual agreement, and government procurement and competition policy. In all negotiations, there are gives and takes. However, the benefits for membership of the few developing countries that are likely to be part of this pact are expected to be enormous.

TPP began as an agreement among four small Asia-Pacific countries (Brunei, Chile, New Zealand and Singapore) in 2005. As of June 2012, the following countries are now part of this agreement and they are negotiating the master agreement among themselves before closure: Australia, Malaysia, Peru, Japan, United States, Vietnam, Canada, and Mexico.

It will be a great pity if the Philippines were to miss out during the formative stage of this new international arrangement. Yet Philippine protective policies on a number of critical economic issues are precisely the factors that prevent us from entering this new club.

Thus, our country is not even yet likely to become a member of this negotiating agreement because of its constitutional situation.

“Move from extractive to inclusive nationalism.” The final argument is related to the notion of nationalism which is often used as the argument for protection. These policies have favored producers at the expense of consumers who have been forced to buy the produce at higher prices. Moreover, the limited impact on economic growth has led to small employment effect that we now know to have happened.

It will take more space to explain why the high objectives of promoting a wrong brand of nationalism in our laws have only led us astray in economic accomplishments. This is an indication of national frustration, that today our economic development has been eclipsed by the accomplishment of neighbors that used to look up to us as a model nation.

My email is: gpsicat@gmail.com. Visit this site for more information, feedback and commentary: http://econ.upd.edu.ph/gpsicat/


Political Law: Senate's distributes "Savings"

Enrile's 'cash gifts' exclude 4 critics

RAPPLER (Jan 2013) – “It is time to call a spade a spade.”

Senate President Juan Ponce Enrile confirmed that he refused to give 4 senators additional funds under the Senate’s Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses or MOOE before the Christmas break.

Enrile issued a statement on Wednesday, January 9, admitting that he refused to give "further additional MOOE" for Senators Miriam Defensor Santiago, Alan Peter Cayetano, Pia Cayetano and Antonio Trillanes IV – either his vocal critics or members of the Senate minority.

The Senate President was responding to a Philippine Daily Inquirer report that came out Wednesday. The report said he gave 18 senators P1.6 million each as a cash gift billed as “additional MOOE” but he approved only P250,000 each to the 4 senators mentioned.

In his statement, Enrile said that all 23 senators got the first tranche of additional MOOE amounting to P600,000 each last November.

“It is not true that the 4 Senators did not get any additional MOOE. They each got P600,000. On top of that, I have approved ALL their requests for cash advances, realignment of various items in their respective Senator’s, Committee and Oversight Committee budgets to their MOOE so that they could use the same and any savings therefrom," Enrile said.

Yet he admitted that he excluded himself and the 4 senators from the second tranche released before the Christmas break. The rest of the 18 senators were given the balance divided into two tranches of P1.3 million and P318,000.

“I stand by the exercise of my sole discretion not to authorize any further release of ADDITIONAL MOOE last December to the 4 senators,” Enrile said.

“It is time to call a spade a spade.”

“Senators Alan Peter Cayetano, Pia Cayetano and Antonio Trillanes are supposedly members of the Minority in the Senate. On the other hand, Senator Santiago’s supposed membership in the Majority is questionable to say the least, as she has publicly and repeatedly denounced and attacked me, just like Sen Trillanes.”

“She does not consider me a friend and I do not think she considers me as the head of the Senate and that is fine with me. Yet, masquerading as a member of the Majority, Sen Santiago continues to hold the chairmanship of the Committee on Constitutional Amendments plus 2 oversight committees with annual budgets of P15 million and P10 million.”

In an interview over Radyo Inquirer, Santiago called on the Commission on Audit to look into the so-called "savings" or "secret funds" of the Senate President, House Speaker and lawmakers.

She said every month, each senator receives P2.2 million for staff salaries and office expenses but has the discretion over the funds and "can pocket the money if he wants to."

“The so-called savings of each public office has turned into a national scandal, the grandmama of all scandals. The Constitution allows savings to be used by the office at the end of the year. But in reality, the head of office manipulates the books and creates so-called savings, by refusing to fill up vacancies, or refusing to buy essential office supplies or services, or capital equipment.”

“These so-called ‘enforced savings’ are then distributed among the highest officials, in the guise of Christmas bonuses,” Santiago said.

Trillanes said Enrile was playing favorites.

‘Joker only real minority, so unlike Cayetanos’
For Trillanes and the Cayetanos, Enrile said they retain leadership of various Senate committees despite being in the minority:
  • Trillanes is chairman of the Civil Service Committee and Oversight Committee on Government Procurement with a budget of P10 million annually, recently just increased to P15 million
  • Alan Peter Cayetano, as minority leader, has a bigger budget than other senators. He also has a budget as a member of the Commission on Appointments, chairman of the E-Commerce Oversight Committee with an annual budget of P6 million, and a new oversight committee chairmanship he requested to be created with an annual budget of P10 million
  • Pia Cayetano chairs the Committee on Health and the Committee on Youth, Women and Family Relations, and the Clean Water Act oversight committee with an annual budget of 10 million.
Enrile said, “Sen Joker Arroyo is the only member of the Minority who really and actually acts as a member of the Minority, doing his job at fiscalizing even more than the Minority Floor Leader.”
“He declined to chair any committee, regular or oversight, so unlike the Cayetano siblings,” Enrile added.
Miriam: He returned biscuits so I returned cash
The Senate President said he even granted the “lambing” of some senators to give P250,000 checks as “pamasko” (Christmas gift) for them but decided to give all senators the amount out of his office’s savings, not from the Senate President’s discretionary funds.
“Last Monday, I was told that Sen Santiago sent me back a check for the same amount of P250,000 with a letter from her Chief of Staff explaining that the check I gave was inadvertenly deposited.”
“So Sen Santiago gave back my gift as I gave back hers. Fair enough,” Enrile said.
In her radio interview, Santiago admitted returning the cheque. "He returned my biscuits so I returned his cash."
Enrile was referring to Santiago’s media statements that she was offended when Enrile returned her Christmas gift of Panaderia de Molo biscuits.
In response, Enrile said last December his staff made a mistake but admitted, “I am not a hypocrite. When I don’t like a person, I don’t like a person.”
In a text message, Trillanes also said, "I confirm that my office received a cheque of P250,000 from the Office of the Senate President last December which my office used to fund relief missions to the affected areas by Typhoon Pablo in Northern Mindanao. It was not given in cash and was not specified as a Christmas gift."
Enrile and the 4 senators have been on opposing sides in various issues. He admitted having a deep-seated animosity with Santiago from the days he was still Secretary of Justice. Santiago has described their relationship as "ice-cold."
The two again clashed on controversial measures last year like the Reproductive Health (RH) law and the sin tax reform law. Santiago and the Cayetanos pushed for the passage of the two laws while Enrile staunchly opposed the measures.
Enrile and Trillanes had a verbal spat on the Senate floor last year, when Trillanes bolted the majority and accused Enrile of railroading the bill dividing Camarines Sur.
Enrile responded by claiming that Trillanes sided with the Chinese in back-door negotiations on the territorial dispute over Scarborough Shoal. The Senate President used as basis supposed notes of then Ambassador to China Sonia Brady.
OLD RIVALRY. Enrile and Sen Miriam Defensor Santiago admit they have a deep-seated rivalry. Santiago warns of a plot to unseat Enrile as Senate President. File photo by Joe Arazas/Senate PRIB OLD RIVALRY. Enrile and Sen Miriam Defensor Santiago admit they have a deep-seated rivalry. Santiago warns of a plot to unseat Enrile as Senate President. File photo by Joe Arazas/Senate PRIB
Selective giving?
Enrile insisted that he exercised “prudence and equity” in handling Senate funds but stood by his decision not to give more money to his 4 critics.
“The only thing I find humorous about this whole controversy is that I am being accused of ‘giving,’ albeit generously to most but not as generously to a few … 4 to be exact.”
He responded to reports that the release of the funds could be interpeted as a “bribe” to retain the Senate Presidency when session resumes on January 21.
Trillanes and Santiago have warned of a plot to unseat Enrile because of his stand on the two administration measures, and his position as a leader of the opposition United Nationalist Alliance (UNA).
Enrile said, “Those Senators who think that I am bribing anyone with additional budgets in order to keep my post as Senate President must have a very low opinion about their own colleagues.”
“I was elected as Senate President twice and I can look at anyone straight in the eye in saying that I did not buy this position. Not one single centavo of the people’s money is spent just to enable me to cling to this office,” Enrile added.
Regular practice?
Rappler was able to get in touch with 3 senators who said they are still checking with their accountants and finance officers the amount they got in MOOE last Christmas.
Senators Gregorio Honasan II and Ralph Recto said they were also not aware of the amounts their colleagues got.
They explained that the MOOE is regularly given to senators to fund official expenses like committee hearings and is not meant for personal use. They said the amount is subject to liquidation and auditing.
“We do receive the savings at the end of the year like in previous years. We received something like this in the past but I do not know if it reached this magnitude,” Recto said referring to the P1.6 million.
Asked about comments anonymous senators made in the Inquirer report that what Enrile did was “unconscionable and unconstitutional,” Recto said, “That is for the Commission on Audit to determine.”
Recto is a member of the ruling Liberal Party. Amid reports of a Senate coup last year, he was named as the person being eyed to replace Enrile as Senate President.
“I have said it clearly. I am not interested in the post and I do not think this has any connection. There has never been bribery for the Senate Presidency. Usually, the factors [in the change of leadership] are party affiliation, personal relationship with other senators and the leadership of the committees,” Recto said in a phone interview.
Recto added, “This is my second term in the Senate. I have never heard of the MOOE being a factor in the vote for senate presidency.”
Sen Aquilino "Koko" Pimentel III said he was only aware of the P250,000 cheque.
Pimentel said in a text message, "My Chief of Staff told me last January 7 that the Senate President sent a cheque as 'Christmas gift.' I asked how much? She replied P250,000. And I replied same as last year, referring to 2011."
Honasan: Bring Enrile to court if you want
Honasan, an Enrile ally in the so-called Senate macho bloc, defended the Senate President.
“I don’t think it’s in the character of the Senate President to offer bribes to retain his position. He’s been quoted as saying he is ready to step down because he is getting tired,” he said in a phone interview.
Honasan said the process is that senators will request for additional MOOE from the Office of the Senate President and it is up to Enrile to grant or deny the request or give even more funds.
“To my best recollection, we do not get this only in Christmas but even midyear, during enrollment when employees will need cash advance for their children. There is no fixed amount. It depends on variables like savings.”
“The Senate President has discretion. He is the administrator of the Senate. We assume regularity. I presume no malice on both sides,” Honasan said.
On questions on the constitutionality of Enrile’s move, Honasan said, “That’s the problem when you (anonymous sources) don’t want to be identified. If you think it’s unconstitutional then challenge it before the Supreme Court. Take the Senate President to court.”
Honasan though admitted that there was “percolating tension” between Enrile and other “strong personalities” in the Senate resulting from the recent debates on the RH and sin tax laws.
Asked how the release of the MOOE will affect the Senate, Recto said, “It’s possible we will hold a caucus. It will be at the back of the mind of the senators.” – Rappler.com
Below is Enrile’s statement in full:
It is unfortunate that the Inquirer either refused to reveal or was requested by the Senators that its reporters interviewed to hide their identities, in relation to their statements on the issue of the additional MOOE of P1.6M I allegedly gave as “cash gifts” to 18 Senators.
To set the record straight:
1. While it is true that the vacant seat of one Senator is a source of additional funds for the Senate, the budget for that seat is not the only source of the Senate’s savings. As agreed in the past with all the Senators, the savings from the vacant seat may be used for the other expenditures and requirements of the Senate, including the augmentation of the budgets of the Senators serving their terms.
2. Hence, towards the end of each year and before the holidays, the Senate Secretariat and the Senate’s budget office makes a determination of how much savings we have generated and how to allocate available savings, including the Christmas package for the Senate employees, what is due under the Collective Negotiation Agreement with the employees union (S.E.N.A.D.O), and what may be available for distribution as additional MOOE to the Senators’ offices.
3. Since I became Senate President in November of 2008, I have always prioritized the needs of our employees before determining and exercising my discretion on the utilization of the remaining available savings. The records will show that since I became Senate President, I have granted the maximum benefits to our employees as our budgetary savings allow each year.
4. Also as Senate President, I have authorized the grant to ALL Senators of the following amounts per Senator’s office as additional MOOE (Maintenance and Other Operating Expenses): For 2008-1M (former Senate President Villar had earlier released a separate amount of P500,000); for 2009- 1M; for 2010- P1.316M; P318,000; for 2011- P500,000, P1.3M, and P318,000.
5. All the Senators, including those now complaining or calling it “unconscionable” and “unconstitutional” received these amounts. Yet they never said anything nor questioned it before.
6. For year-end of 2012, the Senate budget office advised me that after all our obligations and projected expenses, the available amount for the additional MOOE for the Senators was a total of P2.218M for each Senator. The 1st tranche of this was in the amount of P600,000 and ALL THE 23 SENATORS’ OFFICES RECEIVED THE P600,000 additional MOOE last November.
7. The balance was divided into 2 tranches of P1.3M and P318,000 in addition to the first P600,000, and these 2 tranches were approved by me for release before the Christmas holiday break, EXCEPT TO MYSELF AND 4 OTHER SENATORS, NAMELY, SENATORS ALAN CAYETANO, PIA CAYETANO, ANTONIO TRILLANES AND MIRIAM DEFENSOR SANTIAGO.
8. I confirm that I gave the instructions to my Chief of Staff to exclude me and the 4 other Senators in the succeeding releases of any further additional MOOE. I also confirm that, as requested by the Senate Budget office, I approved the use of the amounts that I waived and those that I did not authorize to be released to the 4 Senators to be used by the Senate for its other expenditures. This is all on record.
It is not true that the 4 Senators did not get any additional MOOE. They each got P600,000. On top of that, I have approved ALL their requests for cash advances, realignment of various items in their respective Senator’s, Committee and Oversight Committee budgets to their MOOE so that they could use the same and any savings therefrom.
Any additional MOOE approved by the Senate President for each Senator is not a matter of ENTITLEMENT. Neither should such be mistaken as taken from the Senate President’s DISCRETIONARY FUNDS. The expenditures charged to the OSP’s discretionary funds are properly documented and I have made the same available even for the contingencies of the Secretariat and the needs of some Committees and Senators, as they would request from time to time.
While it is said to be purely discretionary on the part of the Senate President what additional budget to grant out of savings, or to give any at all for that matter, I have exercised such discretion with prudence and equity, and I have given the maximum that we could grant to all the Senators concerned.
I stand by the exercise of my sole discretion not to authorize any further releases of ADDITIONAL MOOE last December to the 4 Senators.
It is time to call a spade a spade.
Senators Alan Peter Cayetano, Pia Cayetano and Antonio Trillanes are supposedly members of the Minority in the Senate. On the other hand, Senator Santiago’s supposed membership in the Majority is questionable, to say the least, as she has publicly and repeatedly denounced and attacked me, just like Sen. Trillanes. She does not consider me a friend and I do not think she considers me as the head of the Senate and that is fine with me.
Yet, masquerading as a member of the Majority, Sen. Santiago continues to hold the chairmanship of the Committee on Constitutional Amendments plus 2 oversight committees with annual budgets of P15M and P 10M.
Sen. Trillanes, despite his move to the Minority, has retained the chairmanship of the Civil Service Committee and of the Oversight Committee on Government Procurement with a budget of P10 Million annually which was just recently increased to P15M.
The Minority Leader, Sen. Alan Cayetano, being an Officer of the Senate, has a bigger budget than the other Senators. He also has a budget as a member of the Commission on Appointments, the chairmanship of the E-Commerce Oversight Committee with an annual budget of P6M, and now a new oversight committee chairmanship (BCDA) which he requested to be created with an annual budget of P10M.
Senator Pia Cayetano chairs the Committee on Health and the Committee on Youth, Women and Family Relations plus the Clean Water Act oversight committee with an annual budget of P10M.
Sen. Joker Arroyo is the only member of the Minority who really and actually acts as a member of the Minority, doing his job at fiscalizing even more than the Minority Floor Leader. He declined to chair any committee, regular or oversight, so unlike the Cayetano siblings.
Regarding the P250,000 checks from my Office which I gave to all the Senators, that was a result of the “lambing” of some Senators who I will no longer name, if I had some “pamasko” for them. I decided to give to ALL, not only to those who were teasing me about “pamasko”, OUT OF MY OWN OFFICE’S SAVINGS, AND NOT FROM THE SENATE PRESIDENT’S DISCRETIONARY FUNDS.
Last Monday, I was told that Sen. Santiago sent me back a check for the same amount of P250,000 with a letter from her Chief of Staff explaining that the check I gave was inadvertently deposited. So Sen. Santiago gave back my gift, as I gave back hers. Fair enough.
The only thing I find humorous about this whole controversy is that I am being accused of “giving”, albeit generously to most, but not as generously to a few…4 to be exact.
Those Senators who think that I am bribing anyone with additional budgets in order to keep my post as Senate President must have a very low opinion about their own colleagues. I was elected as Senate President twice and I can look at anyone straight in the eye in saying that I did not buy this position. Not one single centavo of the people’s money is spent just to enable me to cling to this office.
Each one of us must account to the people how we spend taxpayer’s money as we perform our jobs. I continue to serve solely at the pleasure of the majority of the members of the chamber, and we all owe it to the institution and the people to keep its honor and dignity.

Monday, January 14, 2013

Aquino open to joint oil dev’t of Recto Bank, but …



Inquirer (January 14, 2013) - President Aquino is open to the idea of a Chinese company joining an oil and gas exploration in Recto Bank in the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) but says it has to comply with Philippine laws.

The prospective partner, China National Offshore Oil Corp. or CNOOC, has to recognize that Recto Bank is part of Philippine territory, the President said. 

“We’re talking about Recto Bank here. We can’t split Recto Bank with them. Recto Bank is ours. If they want to join, why not? We’re open to investors but they should comply with our laws,” Mr. Aquino said in Thursday’s dialogue with Radio Mindanao Network reporters.

“We believe in our own laws, that there should be dispute resolution. It should be clear that [what] we’re getting into is ours and we will respect what is theirs,” he added.

Ma Keqing, the Chinese ambassador to the Philippines, said both countries should push ahead with a plan to explore oil and gas in Recto Bank, which contained potential reserves of 3.4 trillion cubic feet of gas and 440 million barrels of oil.

The first step, she said, was for both countries to clear CNOOC and the Forum Energy-led consortium of businessmen Manuel V. Pangilinan and Enrique Razon to sign an agreement to confirm and maximize the potential minerals in Recto Bank, off the coast of Palawan province.

The joint cooperation would be the best way for both countries, she said.

The proposal for a joint exploration came amid Manila’s ongoing standoff with Beijing over Panatag Shoal (Scarborough Shoal), a group of coral and rock formations in the West Philippine Sea, where Philippine and Chinese vessels faced off in April 2012.

China claims sovereignty over nearly all of the sea, believed to sit atop vast amounts of oil and gas. The West Philippine Sea is also one of the region’s most important fishing grounds and has shipping lanes that are vital to global trade.

The Philippines, Vietnam, Brunei, Malaysia and Taiwan claim parts of the sea.
In the dialogue, Mr. Aquino said CNOOC had a proposal for a joint venture with Forum Energy, which had obtained an exploration license from the government.

“If they have an arrangement to partner, we don’t object. But it has to conform with Philippine laws,” Mr. Aquino said.

‘Workable’
Briefing reporters on the visit of Japanese Foreign Minister Fumio Kishida to Manila, Foreign Secretary Albert del Rosario on Thursday said that the joint venture would be “workable” if CNOOC complies with Philippine laws.

“When we speak of what’s possible, there are service contracts there that have been put out by the government, which is in accordance with the Philippine law,” Del Rosario said.

“Now, provided they do a joint venture with a holder of this service contract and they adhere to all the conditions of the service contract—which is consistent with Philippine law and not in violation of our Constitution—I think that might be workable,” he added.

Within EEZ
Pangilinan and Razon are joint holders of Service Contract No. 72, the state-granted exploration franchise covering 80,000 hectares in Recto Bank, which lies within the 330-kilometer exclusive economic zone (EEZ) under the Philippine Archipelagic Baselines Law.

Pangilinan’s Philex Mining, through its subsidiaries FEC Resources Inc. and Philex Petroleum, owns a controlling 64.45 percent of Forum Energy, which holds 70 percent of SC 72. The remaining 30 percent of SC 72 is owned by Razon’s Monte Oro Resources and Energy Inc.

Pangilinan met with CNOCC officials last year for a possible tie-up but Razon said Monte Oro was not too keen on getting a Chinese partner for its share in SC 72.

Mr. Aquino is adamant that all royalties go to the Philippines because Recto Bank is clearly inside its EEZ, being 150 km off Palawan while Hainan, the nearest Chinese territory, is 570 km away.
Forum was scheduled in October 2012 to check the soil stability in the area in preparation for an appraisal well drilling in the first or second quarter of this year. But the Department of Energy refused to give Forum the go-signal pending the resolution of the territorial row with China.
Under the watch of then President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo, CNOOC, Petron Corp. of the Philippines and Vietnam Oil and Gas Corp. agreed to explore the potential for oil in disputed waters under the Joint Maritime Seismic Understanding in 2005.
 
This was criticized as unconstitutional for failing to comply with the 40-percent foreign ownership limit on join exploration deals involving natural resources of the Philippines. But Ma said this was “a very valid formula” pending the solution of the territorial row.